You've found a new role, handed in your notice, and then your manager comes back with more money and a promise of change. It's flattering, and it's tempting. But accepting a counter-offer isn't always the right decision.

Why employers make counter-offers Losing a skilled IT professional is costly and disruptive. Recruiting and training a replacement takes time, and projects can stall. A counter-offer is often the quickest fix, but it may not address the reasons you wanted to leave.

Questions to ask yourself

  • Why did I start looking? If it was purely about pay, a raise may resolve it. If it was about progression, culture, workload, management or the technology you work with, extra money rarely changes those things.
  • Why wasn't I offered this sooner? If a pay rise was only available once you resigned, consider what that says about how your contribution is valued.
  • How will things feel afterwards? Some people worry that colleagues or managers view them differently after handing in their notice, which can affect trust and future opportunities.
  • Is the offer genuine? Are the promises in writing? A verbal commitment to a promotion "in six months" is very different from a confirmed change to your contract.
  • What am I giving up? The new role may offer better technology, career growth, flexibility or a stronger team. Weigh these carefully against a salary increase alone.

When accepting can make sense

A counter-offer may be worth considering if the underlying issue was genuinely pay or a specific fixable problem, the employer has addressed it formally in writing, and you'd have been happy to stay if it had been resolved earlier.

How to handle it professionally

  • Be honest and courteous with both employers
  • Take time to think rather than deciding on the spot
  • Talk it through with someone you trust, including your recruiter
  • If you turn it down, do so graciously. The industry is smaller than it looks

A word on notice periods UK IT contracts commonly include notice periods of one to three months, so check your terms before making commitments to a new employer. 

Weighing up an offer? The TPNTECH team can talk through your options in confidence.